Cooperation with the Liberals

1871 – 1878

The founding of the German Empire took place with general popular approval. But not all Germans erupted in joy. Some disliked the fact that the German question had been answered in a Lesser German way and with centralised institutions. Others criticised the military means used. Many also considered the political system to be flawed, as reflected in an appeal by the liberal Offenburg politician Carl Eckhard . It was necessary, he said, "to win for the now united Germany in time that which gives our work of unification its final and highest consecration – a healthy development of the entire constitutional life of the German state."

The constitutional order of the German Empire

The fulfilment of Eckhard's wish did not seem at all unrealistic. For the unmistakable conservative tendencies towards perseverance were contrasted by remarkable elements of new beginnings. A glance at the imperial constitution makes this clear: the empire was a constitutional and federal monarchy in which the princes exercised supreme state power. The Emperor acted as the Presidency of the Federation together with the Bundesrat (Federal Council). An Imperial Chancellor, who was solely responsible to him, conducted the affairs of government.

Reichstag 1874A session of the German Reichstag, Bismarck is sitting on the government bench on the left. Taken from nature by H. Lüders, published as a black and white drawing in: Die Gartenlaube, 1874.
Colored print (© Otto-von-Bismarck-Stiftung)
The Federal Council was also the executive power and part of the legislature. In accordance with its size and power, Prussia had a clear preponderance in it. Nevertheless, the federal order left the other federal states a great deal of leeway in asserting their political interests. The princes also had to take into account the second legislative body, the Reichstag. Its strength was based not least on the fact that it represented the people. The members of parliament were elected by universal, equal, direct and secret suffrage. All men over the age of 25 were eligible to vote. The Federal Council and the Imperial Chancellor could not govern without the consent of the Reichstag. All laws, especially the budget, which had to be passed annually, had to be approved by it.

Through the separation of powers, through universal suffrage, which is a "fundamental politicization" (Hans Peter Ullmann) of the population, and due to the basic rights found in the state constitutions, the empire was not a purely authoritarian state. But it cannot be called a parliamentary monarchy. However, the constitutional order certainly contained possibilities for further development towards a parliamentary system.

 

Bismarck's Cooperation with the Liberals

In the first years after the founding of the Reich, Bismarck cooperated primarily with the National Liberals on the parliamentary level. With their approval, a host of fundamental reforms could be passed: the Commercial Code, a uniform penal code, a new stock corporation law, the introduction of a common currency as well as Empire-wide weights and measures. Rudolf Delbrueck, President of the Imperial Chancellery, was largely in charge. Bismarck rarely intervened in the legislative processes. However, he resolutely supported the liberal economic policy because for him it was the prerequisite for economic prosperity and thus political stability. The two sides also cooperated smoothly in the Kulturkampf.

From the point of view of the national liberals, the successes achieved gave hope that the "unity" of the German Reich would soon be followed by "freedom". But these dreams were shattered when liberal ideas were discredited as a result of the "Great Depression" of 1873. With the worldwide economic slump, the Reich fell into financial as well as economic difficulties. Although, with the exception of the agricultural sector, a certain recovery set in from the end of the 1870s, the consensus on the economic and socio-political principles that had prevailed until then increasingly dissolved.

 5 marks German EmpireWith the mark, Germany received a common currency on January 1, 1876.
Five mark coin (© Otto-von-Bismarck-Stiftung)

The domestic political turn of 1878

When the Liberals lost their key parliamentary position in the 1878 Reichstag elections, it apparently no longer seemed possible from Bismarck's perspective to provide liberal answers to the central political questions. He therefore took refuge in a fundamental change of direction in domestic policy, thus ending the liberal era of his Imperial Chancellorship. As a result, free trade was replaced by a broad protective tariff system, the Kulturkampf was toned down and the Anti-Socialist Laws were enforced. This profound break in the history of the empire severely disappointed the Liberals since their cooperation with the monarchy had not brought to the longed-for bourgeois freedom any closer.

However, Bismarck was not only concerned with a change from a liberal to a conservative policy; the quest for new tax revenues for the empire rather made it clear that with the domestic political turnaround he also intended to strengthen the imperial institutions.

 Bismarck at the wheel caricatureAt the wheel, caricature, from: Kladderadatsch, 1879. Bismarck's cooperation with the liberals was not to last, the caption says pragmatically: "The liberal spoke to the other two: Don't get too arrogant! As soon as the wind shifts, I'll be up again." (Public domain)